Fix it or replace it?
Quick answer: repair when the appliance is in good shape and the failed part is a single, common part: a fan, valve, fuse, belt, pump, igniter or control. Lean toward replacing when the repair is a large share of the price of a comparable new appliance and the unit is near the end of its life, or when it has needed several repairs in a short time.
Three questions
- What failed? Single parts are usually worth it. Major assemblies on older budget appliances, such as a sealed system or tub bearings, often are not.
- How old is it and how has it been treated? A well-kept appliance with one failure is different from one with rust, cracked parts and a history of problems.
- What would a comparable new one cost, installed? Built-in and premium appliances cost much more to replace, and replacing them can mean cabinet work. Repair usually wins there.
By appliance
| Appliance | Usually worth repairing | Often not worth it on older budget units |
|---|---|---|
| Refrigerator | Fans, relays, defrost parts, valves, ice makers, boards | Compressor or refrigerant leak |
| Dryer | Fuses, elements, igniters, belts, rollers, switches | Rusted-through drum |
| Washer | Pumps, locks, door boots, hoses, boards | Tub bearings, cracked outer tub |
We give you the repair price first and tell you plainly when we think replacing makes more sense. The $89 diagnostic is all you pay if you decide not to repair.